Homemade Biscoff Cookie Butter Ice Cream

This post contains affiliate links. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases, at no extra cost to you.

Day 2 of turning my cravings into ice cream flavors, and this one came directly from a leftover half-jar of cookie butter sitting in my cabinet after I made my Gooey Biscoff French Toast Bites. I couldn’t just let it sit there. So into the ice cream machine it went, and this homemade Biscoff cookie butter ice cream came out: loaded with that spiced cookie flavor, crumbled Biscoff cookies folded in, a ribbon of extra cookie butter swirled through. And if you don’t love cookie butter? You’re a monster. Scientific fact.

Get Recipe Ingredients

View this reel on Instagram

What Is the Flavor of Biscoff Cookie Butter?

Biscoff cookie butter (also sold as Biscoff spread) is made from those caramelized Belgian spiced cookies you get on airplanes. It has a warm, brown sugar and cinnamon flavor with a hint of something almost like gingerbread. It’s not peanut butter, not Nutella, it’s its own thing entirely. In ice cream form, that spiced flavor comes through in every bite, which is why this biscoff cookie butter ice cream is SO different from anything else in your freezer. My Biscoff Marshmallow Treats capture the same warm, caramelized cookie vibe in a totally different format if you want another way to use up a jar.

What Makes This Biscoff Cookie Butter Ice Cream So Good

The base is built from loosened cookie butter whisked into heavy cream, whole milk, light brown sugar, and vanilla. You get a full cookie butter flavor in every spoonful rather than just a swirl on top. Then the crumbled Biscoff cookies fold in during the last few minutes of churning. If you eat it fresh out of the machine, the cookies are still crunchy and the texture is WILD. Once frozen, they soften a little, but the ice cream firms up and becomes more scoopable.

Does Trader Joe’s have cookie butter ice cream? Some stores carry a seasonal version, but making it at home with the actual Biscoff spread means you control the ratio, you can do the cookie swirl, and the flavor hits different. Worth making from scratch.

Tips for Making Biscoff Cookie Butter Ice Cream

1. Warm the Cookie Butter Before Mixing

Biscoff spread is thick and stiff at room temperature. Microwave it for a few seconds or whisk a splash of warmed heavy cream into it first until it loosens up and is pourable. Cold, stiff cookie butter won’t blend smoothly into the cream base.

2. Chill the Base Before Churning

This is listed as optional in the recipe, but a cold base always churns smoother and faster in a compressor machine. If you have the time, cover and refrigerate the mixture for at least 30 minutes before running the program.

3. Keep Crumble Pieces Varied in Size

Some big shards, some finer crumbs. The variety of textures is what makes the mix-in interesting. All fine and you lose the crunch. All big and the pieces are hard to eat.

4. Add Cookies in the Last 3 Minutes

If you drop them in too early, they get fully blended into the base and you lose the distinct cookie texture. Three minutes before the program ends is the sweet spot: they incorporate but stay as identifiable pieces.

5. For the Swirl, Fold Just 2-3 Times

Once you drizzle the warmed extra Biscoff spread over the churned ice cream, fold it in only 2-3 times. Any more and you end up with a fully blended base instead of a visible ribbon. The same principle applies to any ice cream with mix-ins, like my Homemade Ube Oreo Ice Cream: restraint on the folding is what keeps swirls and ribbons visually distinct.

Storage and Leftovers

Transfer the ice cream to a chilled airtight container and freeze until firm, usually 2-4 hours. Once frozen solid, it keeps well for up to 2 weeks. The Biscoff cookies will soften over time in the freezer, so if you want maximum crunch, eat it sooner rather than later. Let the container sit at room temperature for 3-5 minutes before scooping if it’s been frozen solid for a while.

Equipment

• Ice cream maker (compressor-style)
• Mixing Bowls
• Whisk

Ingredients

• 1.5 cups Heavy Cream
• 1/2 cup whole milk
• 1/2 cup biscoff spread (smooth)
• 3 tbsp light brown sugar (packed)
• 1 tsp Vanilla Extract
• a pinch of fine sea salt
• 10 biscoff cookies (coarsely crumbled)
• 3 tbsp biscoff spread (for optional swirl)
• caramel syrup (to taste, for topping)

Instructions

1. Loosen the cookie butter by gently warming the 1/2 cup of biscoff spread (a few seconds in the microwave, or whisk it with a splash of warmed Heavy Cream) until loose and pourable.
2. Whisk the warmed cookie butter with the Heavy Cream, whole milk, light brown sugar, Vanilla Extract, and fine sea salt until completely smooth with no lumps.
3. Cover and refrigerate the base for 30 minutes if you have time (optional but recommended for a smoother churn).
4. Coarsely crumble the biscoff cookies, keeping some bigger shards for texture. Set aside a handful for topping.
5. Pour the base into your ice cream maker and run the ice cream program until thick and scoopable.
6. In the last 3 minutes of churning, fold in the crumbled cookies. For the swirl, warm the remaining 3 tbsp of biscoff spread until pourable, drizzle it over the churned ice cream, and fold just 2-3 times to create ribbons.
7. Scoop soft right away for crunchy cookies, or transfer to a chilled airtight container and freeze 2-4 hours to firm up. Top with reserved crumbled cookies and caramel syrup to serve.

Eat this one fresh out of the machine if you can. It firms up fine in the freezer, but straight from the churn is when the texture is at its best and the crumbled cookie pieces still have some snap left in them.

And look, if you don’t love cookie butter I don’t know what to tell you. Scientific fact. 🙌

If you make this biscoff cookie butter ice cream, leave a star rating on the recipe card below and drop a comment! Ratings help other readers discover it, and I’d love to hear how it turned out.

Print