Cheesy Honey Butter Toast

This post contains affiliate links. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases, at no extra cost to you.

Honey toast with melted cheese in the middle. Just DO IT. (Yes, that was my best Shia LaBeouf impression, and no, I don’t regret it.) 🍞 This cheesy honey butter toast is soft white bread fried in a honey brown sugar butter until the outside goes crunchy and caramelized, with a fold of gooey mozzarella pulling apart in the middle. Sweet, savory, crispy, melty, and I get all of it out of five ingredients and one pan in about ten minutes. If you’ve had honey toast before but never like THIS, you’re seriously missing out!

Get Recipe Ingredients

View this reel on Instagram

What Makes This Cheesy Honey Butter Toast So Good

I made a chocolate version of this a while back and it’s incredible, but this one right here is the OG. You fry the bread in that honey and brown sugar butter and the sugars caramelize straight onto the crust, so it actually crackles when you bite it. Then the mozzarella hiding in the middle goes stretchy and molten. Crunchy outside, cheese pull inside, sweet meeting savory in every bite. SO good!

And if putting sugar on something savory sounds off to you, I promise it isn’t. It’s the same idea behind my gilgeori toast, where a light sprinkle of sugar goes right on top of a savory egg and Spam sandwich. Sweet and salty just works, and here the honey does that job while the cheese keeps it anchored!

Tips for Making Cheesy Honey Butter Toast

1. Keep the heat medium-low

This is the whole game and it’s the one thing I’d really stress. Honey and brown sugar burn fast, so you want a patient medium-low heat that lets the crust go deep golden without scorching. If your pan’s ripping hot, the sugar turns bitter before the cheese has even started melting. Low and slow, flip when it’s golden, and you’re set!

2. Chase the caramelized crust

Once both sides are golden, tilt the pan and roll the edges through the leftover butter and sugar so every single side gets that crisp shell. If you’re into a caramelized sugar top, you’ll get why I’m obsessed with my air fryer creme brulee toast, where you torch a whole sheet of sugar over the bread until it shatters like glass!

3. Let it rest a minute

Pull it out of the pan and give it sixty seconds before you cut in. The caramelized crust firms up as it cools slightly, so that soft, sticky-hot shell turns into a proper crunch. I know waiting is annoying when there’s molten cheese right there, but it’s worth it.

What Bread Works Best for Honey Butter Toast?

Soft, thick white bread. My absolute favorite here is Artesano, because a pillowy loaf like that soaks up the honey butter and still holds its shape, which gives you that fluffy inside against the crisp caramelized outside. Cut the crusts off so every edge caramelizes evenly. Thin sandwich bread works in a pinch, but it goes stiff on you, so grab the thicker slices if you can.

What Cheese Melts Best in the Middle?

Low moisture mozzarella, no contest! It melts into that long stretchy pull without leaking water into your nice caramelized crust, which is exactly what fresh mozzarella would do to you. Fold the slice in half so you get a thicker molten center. It’s the same cheese I lean on for the stringy pull in my Eggo waffle grilled cheese, where it plays off sweet waffles the same way it plays off honey here.

Storage and Leftovers

This is best hot and fresh, right while the cheese is still molten, so I’d make what you’re going to eat. If you do end up with leftovers, wrap them and keep them in the fridge for up to two days.

Reheat in a dry pan over medium-low or in the air fryer for a few minutes so the crust crisps back up and the cheese loosens again! I’d skip the microwave, which just turns that crust soft and sad.

Equipment

• Frying pan
• Mixing bowls
• Spatula

Ingredients

• 4 slices white bread, crusts removed
• 2 slices mozzarella
• 2 tablespoons unsalted butter, softened
• 2 tablespoons brown sugar
• 2 tablespoons honey

Substitutions and Swaps

• The bread. Brioche or shokupan are both excellent here and arguably even richer. What I’d avoid is anything with a chewy artisan crust, like sourdough, since you want soft bread that goes crisp on the outside, not bread that’s already got a crust of its own.
• The mozzarella. Any good melting cheese works, so provolone or Monterey Jack will both pull nicely. Fresh mozzarella is the one I’d skip, because it releases water and softens the caramelized crust you just worked for.
• The honey. Maple syrup gives you a slightly different, more autumnal thing and it’s really good. It’s thinner though, so it runs off the bread more, and I’d go a touch heavier on the brown sugar to compensate.
• The brown sugar. White sugar caramelizes fine, you just lose that faint molasses depth. Coconut sugar works too and browns even faster, so drop the heat a little if you use it.
• Going savory-only. Leave out the honey and sugar and you’ve basically got a mozzarella grilled cheese, which is great but a completely different sandwich. The sweet crust is the entire point of this one, so I wouldn’t lose it.

Instructions

1. Cut the crusts off all four slices of bread.
2. In a small bowl, mix the softened butter, brown sugar and honey together until it’s well combined.
3. Spread a generous layer of the butter mixture on one side of two slices, then lay them butter-side down in a pan over medium-low heat.
4. Fold a slice of mozzarella in half and set it on top of each piece of bread in the pan.
5. Top each one with a remaining bread slice, then spread more of the butter mixture over the exposed side facing up.
6. Cook until golden brown on both sides, flipping carefully. For a caramelized crust all the way around, tilt the pan and fry the edges in the residual butter too.
7. Take the sandwiches out and let them rest a minute or two, so the caramelized crust firms up as they cool slightly.
8. Cut them in half and eat while the cheese is still pulling.

I made a chocolate version of this a while back and it’s great, but this one is the OG for me. Sweet and caramelized on the outside with savory cheese pulling apart in the middle is a combination I keep coming back to.

Use a thick slice bread if you can, that’s the part that makes the difference. And if you’ve had honey toast before but never like this, you’re missing out. 🙌

If you make this, leave a star rating on the recipe card and let me know in the comments how it went. It really helps other people find the recipe, and I want to know whether you went team OG or team chocolate!

Print